Spoiler alert: Contrary to popular belief, highly sensitive people (HSPs) and empaths are not magnets for narcissists. However, many HSPs and empaths struggle with setting firm personal boundaries. This can leave them vulnerable to narcissistic behavior and might make it feel like they’re attracting them.
So, why do highly sensitive people and empaths often find themselves caught in the narcissist’s web more than others? Here’s why:
Seeing nuance and over-reasoning
HSP and empaths have a deep sensitivity to other people’s pain. With their empathic nature, they naturally want to help. They listen, lean in, and open themselves up to others’ struggles. This makes it easy for them to recognize the wounds behind someone’s behaviors - but this is where things can go sideways…
Understanding someone’s pain doesn’t mean you need to justify their behavior, tolerate it, or make it your problem. It’s okay to say, “I see you’re hurting, but that doesn’t give you the right to treat me poorly.” Excusing someone’s actions won’t fix them - or you. Narcissists, in particular, are happy to take advantage of this compassion.
HSP and empaths also have a knack for spotting all the shades of grey in social dynamics. While others see right vs. wrong, black vs. white, they see all the nuance. This can lead to reasoning away harmful behavior instead of calling it out, which opens the door for narcissistic manipulation. Remember: being understanding doesn’t mean you have to ignore your own needs or let toxic patterns slide.
A reflective nature and self-doubt
HSP and empaths tend to be highly self-reflective, often analyzing their actions, words, and choices to ensure they’re kind and fair. But this habit of introspection can sometimes morph into self-doubt or overthinking. And guess what? Narcissists thrive in that murky pool of uncertainty.
When HSP and empaths question themselves - “Did I handle that right?” “Was I too harsh?” “Should I have done more?” - it creates the perfect opening for narcissists to exploit, blame, and gaslight. This can chip away at confidence and leave HSP and empaths even more vulnerable.
To counter this, it’s important for HSP and empaths to build confidence in their own choices. Let go of the need to socially “perfect” every interaction. Be kind and thoughtful, but also trust your instincts. Your value isn’t tied to pleasing everyone, and honoring your integrity means knowing when it’s being crossed.
The rescuer tendency
HSP and empaths often act like the world’s emotional first responders, swooping in to rescue the “wounded.” But when the wounded turn out to be narcissists, it’s like running straight into the jaws of a wolf in sheep’s clothing. Try to help, and you’ll likely get blamed, bitten, and told you’re the problem. Narcissists don’t want help - they thrive on denial and deflection.
HSP and empaths with loose boundaries might fall into codependent patterns, trying to heal someone who refuses to take responsibility. No amount of love, understanding, or effort will change a narcissist’s behavior. The truth is, you can’t rescue them - but you can take a closer look at why you feel the need to.
Remember: it’s not your job to sacrifice your well-being to help someone else. You can support others while still standing firm against abusive behavior. Boundaries aren’t unkind; they’re necessary.
Conflict avoidance and “keeping the peace”
HSP and empaths often dread conflict - it can feel physically painful. Many will do whatever it takes to keep things harmonious, even if it means ignoring their own needs or burying uncomfortable emotions. Unfortunately, this habit can weaken boundary-setting skills and make them a target for narcissists, who excel at exploiting any lack of boundaries.
If you’re not tuned into your feelings, it’s hard to stand up and say “No, that’s not okay” or “No, I’m not taking responsibility for your reaction.” Without a solid “no,” narcissists will happily push past your limits.
With a narcissist, the moment you engage, you’ve already lost. The only way to win is not to play.
This can be a tough pill to swallow for HSP and empaths who want to fix or “smooth over” every situation. But the hard truth is, you can’t make everything nice - or every relationship work.
Instead of twisting yourself into knots to please others, focus on creating space for loving, respectful connections. Being boundaried may feel uncomfortable at first, but it’s the key to protecting your peace and building healthier relationships.
You want to share your story, your struggles and the battles you won, and be part of our circle of sensitive and intuitive people. Come with us and let's chat with other highly sensitive people!
Join the Highly Sensitive Empaths community:
Sign up for our newsletters to receive information and stories for highly sensitive people.
Comments